History and GovernmentSupreme CourtCases

Agostini v. Felton (1997)


Case Summary

A federal district court and Court of Appeals ruled against New York City, stating that the city could not have public school teachers provide supplemental instruction to disadvantaged students at religious schools during regular school hours. The city then sought Supreme Court review.

The Court's Decision

In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court ruled that a federally-funded program can give supplemental remedial education to disadvantaged children in sectarian schools without violating the Establishment Clause.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote for the majority. Justice O'Connor concluded that the program “does not run afoul of any of three primary criteria we currently use to evaluate whether government aid has the effect of advancing religion: it does not result in governmental indoctrination; define its recipients by reference to religion; or create an excessive entanglement. We therefore hold that a federally funded program providing supplemental, remedial instruction to disadvantaged children on a neutral basis is not invalid under the Establishment Clause when such instruction is given on the premises of sectarian schools by government employees pursuant to a program containing safeguards such as those present here.”

Justice David Souter argued in dissent that the Court was improperly departing from precedents established in other cases. Previous decisions found that similar programs violated the Establishment Clause for three reasons: a program might use State-paid teachers and public funds for religious education purposes; it might give the impression of State-supported religion; and it might subsidize religious education by freeing up money that would have been spent on secular classes.

More on the Case

Although the Court has traditionally interpreted the First Amendment to require a distinct separation between government and religion, the Court has also been sympathetic to government attempts to provide academic assistance to all students regardless of where they attend school. This tension has resulted in some significant developments—some might say inconsistencies—in case law.

Agostini was unusual in that the Supreme Court reviewed—and overturned—its own decision made in a 1985 case, Aguilar v. Felton. The Court agreed to rehear the case based on the petitioners' argument that the composition of the Court had changed; furthermore, the effects of the first ruling had imposed a huge financial burden on the school district. The earlier Aguilar decision had held that supplemental instruction by public school teachers during regular school hours violated the Establishment Clause. Justice Souter relied on this decision in framing his dissent for Agostini.

Federal and State governments have continued to look for ways to support non-religious education in parochial schools without violating the First Amendment. The Education Consolidation and Improvement Act of 1981 provided federal funds to local educational agencies for the purchase of computers and other educational equipment to be lent to public and private schools for “secular, neutral, and nonideological programs.” In Mitchell v. Helms, decided in 2000, the Supreme Court ruled that this type of direct but neutral aid is constitutional.

Source: ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. Used by permission.

Information Please®, ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

stay connected

Sign up for our free email newsletters and receive the latest advice and information on all things parenting.

Enter your email address to sign up or manage your account.

Facebook icon Twitter icon Follow Us on Pinterest

editor’s picks

highlights

3 Fun Thanksgiving Games for Kids
Looking for some great Thanksgiving games to play with your kids? Print our free Pin the Feathers on the Turkey game, Pin the Hat on the Pilgrim game, and Thanksgiving Parade Bingo game for loads of laughs this Turkey Day!

Kindergarten Readiness App Wins Gold
Our Kindergarten Readiness app won the Gold Award of Excellence in the educational category at the 2014 Communicator Awards. This valuable checklist comes with games and activities to help your child practice the essential skills she needs for kindergarten. Download the Kindergarten Readiness app today!

8 Surprising Sources of Caffeine in Kids' Foods
Even low doses of caffeine can have an effect on your child's health. Since the FDA doesn't require caffeine content on food labels, learn about hidden sources of caffeine in kids' diets.

Find Today's Newest & Best Children's Books!
Looking for newly released books for your child? Try our new Book Finder tool to search for new books by age, type, and theme, and create reading lists for kids!