History and GovernmentSupreme CourtCases

Communist Party of Indiana v. Whitcomb (1974)


Case Summary

In 1972, the Communist Party of Indiana was denied a place on the presidential ballot because it refused to provide an affidavit, sworn under oath, that it did not advocate the forcible overthrow of the government. After losing a court challenge, the Party appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Court's Decision

The Court held that the loyalty oath requirement violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments. Justice William Brennan wrote the majority opinion, which was joined by four other justices. He argued that, although older Supreme Court cases had held that advocating violent political economic change was so dangerous that the government could outlaw it entirely, many more recent cases had changed this rule to give more weight to free speech. Brennan further held that the Constitution largely gives the States the power to supervise elections, but they must exercise this power constitutionally. A State may not limit a party's access to the ballot or restrict voters' constitutional right of association merely because members of the party believe in something.

Justice Lewis Powell wrote a concurring opinion in which three other Justices joined. He argued that the majority reached the right result in the case, but for the wrong reasons. In Powell's view, the Court should not have considered the more complex question whether the Indiana oath was constitutional. Since in this case the Republican and Democratic Parties were not required to submit affidavits accepting the oath, he wrote, there was no justification for placing a burden on the Communist Party that was not placed on the other established parties. Powell concluded Indiana had denied the plaintiffs the equal protection of laws under the Fourteenth Amendment.

More on the Case

The Supreme Court has considered other cases in which States attempted to exclude people from voting or to prevent them from running for elected office for a variety of reasons. In Richardson v. Ramirez, 1974, the Court ruled that California could constitutionally prevent convicted felons from voting. Justice Thurgood Marshall dissented from the Court's opinion, arguing that a State cannot “strip ex-felons who have fully paid their debt to society of their fundamental right to vote without running afoul of the Fourteenth Amendment.”Although some people worried that convicted felons might vote to undermine the criminal laws, Marshall relied on Whitcomb to argue that potential differences of opinion or matters of belief cannot be used to exclude anyone from the electoral process.

In Chandler v. Miller, 1997, the Court reviewed a Georgia law requiring candidates for certain State offices to certify that they have received a negative result on a urinalysis drug test within 30 days before qualifying for nomination or election. Writing for the Court, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg found that the testing requirement unconstitutionally interfered with candidates' personal privacy. She relied on Whitcomb to support her argument that “States…enjoy wide latitude to establish conditions of candidacy for State office, but in setting such conditions, they may not disregard basic constitutional protections.”

Source: ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. Used by permission.

Information Please®, ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

stay connected

Sign up for our free email newsletters and receive the latest advice and information on all things parenting.

Enter your email address to sign up or manage your account.

Facebook icon Twitter icon Follow Us on Pinterest

editor’s picks

highlights

3 Fun Thanksgiving Games for Kids
Looking for some great Thanksgiving games to play with your kids? Print our free Pin the Feathers on the Turkey game, Pin the Hat on the Pilgrim game, and Thanksgiving Parade Bingo game for loads of laughs this Turkey Day!

Kindergarten Readiness App Wins Gold
Our Kindergarten Readiness app won the Gold Award of Excellence in the educational category at the 2014 Communicator Awards. This valuable checklist comes with games and activities to help your child practice the essential skills she needs for kindergarten. Download the Kindergarten Readiness app today!

Top Family Movies in Theaters for the Holidays
Taking the kids to the movies is a special family treat for the holidays! Don't miss 2014's best family films in theaters from Thanksgiving through Christmas.

Find Today's Newest & Best Children's Books!
Looking for newly released books for your child? Try our new Book Finder tool to search for new books by age, type, and theme, and create reading lists for kids!